This is a summary/reflection/review/whatever-you-want-to-call-it of the first term (Sept-Dec). Each member of the bilingual department was asked to summarize their experience with the brand new program thus far. Mine turned out to be 3 pages (although I could have turned that into 10), with very little positive feedback. Oops? Well, they were things she needed to hear. It reads as follows:
Obviously I am very passionate about children and care for them a lot. I love working with kids and the students at our school have been wonderful! Sure, there are a few that are a little harder to work with, but they haven’t killed me yet!
Since science is what I am trained to teach, I really enjoy the three hours a week when I get to be in a science class and teach things I am passionate about. The science teacher has been really great about trying to split the teaching evenly between the two of us. She’s also been a great ally and good listener. I also love how excited she is to try new things and think outside of the textbook. Let’s be honest, teaching straight from the book can get pretty boring.
There are a few things related specifically to Monica’s and my job that are challenging. First, teachers often come to class unprepared, which can be very frustrating for us. Sometimes they haven’t picked up the photocopies that we need for the lesson, they still need to go get the CD player so we can do a listening activity, they’re not sure which page of the book they ended on during the previous day’s lesson, they come late to class late or don’t come at all, etc… Also, sometimes teachers will walk away in the middle of the lesson without explaining where they are going and when they’ll be back.
Second, many times Monica and I are not needed at all during certain lessons and some days we spend what seems as little as 30 minutes out of the entire day actually being useful. It can get VERY boring on days like this! However, on these days I sometimes get to spend extra time speaking with the kids, which is nice.
I am currently working with 7 different teachers, which makes it very hard to find time to plan ahead with each of them. Often I do not know what (or if) I am teaching until I arrive in class. If I have any questions about the material (which is pretty often since I’m not trained in most of the subjects I am teaching), there is no time to ask them except in front of the classes which is a waste of their class time and slightly embarrassing for me. I’ve become very honest with the students when I don’t understand what they are doing in class. I explain that I don’t know the answers to their questions because I don’t understand the material either.
Although it means more work for us, I would really appreciate having the chance to proofread all written materials being given to the students in English. If everyone could give us worksheets, readings, tests, etc… at least two days in advance that would be great. There are a lot of mistakes being made in translating from Spanish to English and I could easily fix them if given the opportunity. Some teachers do this and others do not.
As for things that will directly help the students, I have clumped my ideas into 4 categories: Expectations, Assessment, Respect and Skills. These are things that are lacking in many classes, not just at our school but at others around Madrid as well. They are things that I find very valuable and I would be more than happy to help teachers at our school include them in their classes.
Expectations
Clear – In general, teachers have a pretty good idea of what they want each assignment to look like in the end. Students should be given a very detailed description of these expectations for each assignment. If an essay needs to be typed on a computer in size 12 font and the title should be centered and underlined, the students need to be told this! Many times, I am seeing students given tasks by the teacher with no specific directions. Only when they turn the essay in handwritten does the teacher mention that it should have been typed. Or someone will write in pen when the teacher wanted them to write in pencil (but never actually told them to do so). Because the teachers’ expectations are not being met, students are often getting yelled at for doing things “wrong” when they were never told what “right” looks like.
Realistic – Writing in pencil instead of pen is easily doable as long as the students are told to do so. Memorizing 30 vocabulary words per night with no context for how to use them in a sentence, however, is not so doable. Memorizing a 15 paged outline of information that is not included in the textbook and has not been taught in class before the next exam is surely impossible. And yet, these kinds of unrealistic expectations are occurring within the school often.
Equal – I am constantly hearing teachers talk about how the lower classes are composed of “bad kids” and there seems to be an attitude that they can’t do anything. I don’t think that is true. Because teachers start the school year assuming that these students are bad, they begin to treat them like they actually are bad (even if they are not). Yes, C, D, and E are far more challenging to work with than A or B, but they are not bad. They are only 12 years old, none of them are bad yet. However, they are sometimes treated more like animals than kids. They are told constantly that they are bad or stupid or failing their classes, which makes them start to believe these things are true. Giving them easier assignments than the other groups because they are “too stupid” to do the regular work is just insulting. Granted, their English levels are very different so classes taught in English should have simpler vocabulary but the concepts do not need to be any easier. By treating them differently than the A and B groups, teachers are actually making the students behave bad and stupid! If they are not given encouragement and treated with respect now, they will only get worse as they get older.
Assessment
Feedback – Students need to receive feedback throughout each unit. If they do not know whether or not they actually understand the material, mistakes go unfixed and because of this many of them fail the exams. For example, worksheets should not only be assigned a mark, they also need to be given back to the students (before the test) with comments and corrections. It is vitally important to comment on the things they have done well but also correct what they have done wrong. This way, students can use their worksheets as study tools for exams. Exams should also be returned with reasons why points were taken off, not just a bunch of red marks and their final score. This helps them prepare for future exams by understanding how to improve.
Grades – Students’ grades should never be shared aloud in front of the entire class. It is humiliating! Some students are ashamed when they get low marks and very likely want to keep that information private.
Respect
Although the students are only 12 and 13 years old, they are humans and deserve to be treated with respect. They will not respect a teacher who does not respect them in return. Not only should teachers respect their students, they should also be kind to them. Often teachers scream at them for no (or very little) reason and the students hate it. I see them rolling their eyes behind teachers’ backs and giving each other funny looks. The students are given very few opportunities to act like children. It breaks my heart. You cannot turn 12 year olds into adults overnight.
Skills
Students need to be taught skills, not just facts. Right now, in many of the subjects the students are simply memorizing facts, they are not really learning. When asked “Why?” they think what they do, the answer is almost always “because the book says so” or “because you told us”. They need to be taught how to actually think, how to study, how to take notes, how to communicate, how to raise their hands when they want to speak, how to abbreviate words when they are taking notes in class, how to search for information on Google, etc… If you take one class day to teach them how to highlight the textbook, it will drastically improve their study habits and therefore their test grades for the rest of their lives. I think that that is worth losing one day of class. Similarly, using one day to show them how to make an outline, not copy it off the board but actually make it themselves, would make a world of difference to some of them.